Bessie The Lake Erie Monster

HURON / SANDUSKY / LAKE ERIE ISLANDS REGION • OHIO

Lake Erie Monster Bessie—also called South Bay Bessie, the Lake Erie Monster and sometimes Lemmy—is the modern name attached to more than a century of Lake Erie sea-serpent stories. The legend is real and unusually...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Bethel Cemetery Civil War Soldier Haunting

COOLVILLE • OHIO

Bethel Cemetery near Coolville is the subject of a compact but persistent Athens County ghost story: Civil War soldiers are said to haunt the burial ground, while visitors have also repeated claims of unusual cold...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Cuyahoga River Fire of 1969

CLEVELAND • OHIO

On June 22, 1969, oil-soaked debris floating on Cleveland's Cuyahoga River caught fire beneath railroad bridges in the industrial Flats. The blaze was extinguished quickly and caused comparatively little damage, yet it became one of...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Donald Harvey Angel of Death Serial Killer and Toledo Prison Murder

CINCINNATI|TOLEDO • OHIO

Donald Harvey was one of the most prolific convicted serial killers in American history. Working primarily as a hospital orderly and nurse’s aide in Kentucky and Ohio, he used access to seriously ill patients to...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Edgewood Cemetery McAdams Family Graves

ASHTABULA • OHIO

In the oldest section of Edgewood Cemetery lies a row of weathered McAdams family graves connected to one of Ashtabula's darkest nineteenth-century mysteries. Between 1848 and 1851, five McAdams children and their mother Rebecca died...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Gibbs Bridge

RICHFIELD TOWNSHIP • OHIO

Gibbs Bridge, on Gibbs Road over Tenmile Creek west of Sylvania, became one of northwest Ohio’s best-known haunted-bridge legends. Visitors and paranormal investigators have reported phantom crash sounds, laughter, voices, mist and shadowy figures. The...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Gore Orphanage / Light of Hope

VERMILION • OHIO

Gore Orphanage is one of northern Ohio's most durable ghost stories: children supposedly died when an orphanage burned, and their voices and apparitions are said to remain along a lonely Lorain County road. Historical research...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Great Serpent Mound Archaeology, Myth and Mystery

PEEBLES • OHIO

Serpent Mound is a 1,348-foot-long prehistoric effigy mound in Adams County shaped like an enormous serpent with an oval feature at its head. It is one of Ohio's most recognizable ancient earthworks—and one whose date,...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Johnson’s Island Civil War Prison

MARBLEHEAD • OHIO

Johnson’s Island in Sandusky Bay was the site of a purpose-built Union prisoner-of-war depot that operated from April 1862 to September 1865 and was used primarily for captured Confederate officers. More than 9,000 prisoners passed...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Kirtland Melon Heads

KIRTLAND / CHARDON TOWNSHIP • OHIO

The Kirtland Melon Heads are one of northeast Ohio's best-known urban legends: strange, large-headed figures said to inhabit the woods around Wisner Road near Kirtland and neighboring Chardon Township. The familiar story involves children with...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Loveland Frog

LOVELAND • OHIO

The Loveland Frog is Ohio's best-known humanoid cryptid: a supposedly frog- or lizard-like creature associated with Loveland and the Little Miami River. Its modern reputation rests chiefly on two 1972 police encounters, but the story...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Mansfield Reformatory Haunting Traditions

MANSFIELD • OHIO

The Ohio State Reformatory in Mansfield is one of Ohio's most famous paranormal locations. Its reputation includes stories of shadow figures, disembodied voices, footsteps, unexplained touches and apparitions associated with former prisoners, guards and members...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Matthew Hoffman Mount Vernon Triple Murder, Kidnapping and the Leaf House

MOUNT VERNON | TOLEDO • OHIO

Matthew J. Hoffman is not a serial killer in the usual criminological sense. He is a convicted triple murderer, kidnapper and rapist whose crimes unfolded during one November 2010 attack in Knox County. Three victims...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

McClure Crybaby Hill / Harris-Jones Cemetery

MCCLURE • OHIO

Near McClure in Henry County, Harris-Jones Cemetery is tied to a local 'Crybaby Hill' legend in which motorists are said to hear the cries of an unseen infant or child along a rural road near...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Michigan Dogman

TRAVERSE CITY • MICHIGAN

The Michigan Dogman is described in modern folklore as a large canine-like creature capable of standing or walking upright, usually associated with the forests of northern Michigan. Its familiar history includes an alleged 1887 encounter...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Moonville Tunnel

MOONVILLE • OHIO

Moonville Tunnel is the surviving landmark of a vanished southeastern Ohio railroad community and one of the state's best-known railroad ghost locations.

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Nain Rouge Detroit’s Red Dwarf Omen

DETROIT • MICHIGAN

The Nain Rouge—French for 'red dwarf'—is one of Detroit’s oldest and most distinctive supernatural figures. Modern retellings describe a small red-faced being who appears before disaster, political crisis or personal misfortune, often framing the creature...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Ohio Medical Body Snatching and Grave Robbing

STATEWIDE • OHIO

For much of the nineteenth century, Ohio medical training had a problem that could not be solved politely: students needed human bodies to learn anatomy, while the law supplied almost none. The result was a...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Ohio State Reformatory Helen Glattke Death and Ghost Tradition

MANSFIELD • OHIO

Helen Glattke, wife of Ohio State Reformatory superintendent Arthur Lewis Glattke, died in 1950 after suffering a gunshot wound inside the superintendent's residence. Her death was an actual tragedy, not an invented ghost-story origin. Over...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Ohio’s First Serial Killer Return Jonathan Meigs Ward

SYLVANIA • OHIO

Return Jonathan Meigs Ward is frequently called Ohio’s first serial killer, but the evidence supports the more careful description first presumed or suspected serial killer. Ward was convicted of murdering his wife, Olive Davis Ward,...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Paulding Light Ghost Lantern, Highway Mirage and Michigan’s Mystery Light

PAULDING • MICHIGAN

The Paulding Light is one of Michigan’s most famous anomalous-light traditions. Since the 1960s, observers near Paulding in the western Upper Peninsula have reported a bright light appearing in a distant valley, sometimes changing color,...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Project Blue Book At Wright-Patterson Air Force Base

WRIGHT-PATTERSON AFB • OHIO

Project Blue Book was the U.S. Air Force's longest-running formal investigation of unidentified flying object reports. Headquartered at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, it grew out of earlier Air Force studies known as Project Sign and...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Ravine Cemetery Ghost Bride

SYLVANIA • OHIO

Ravine Cemetery's Ghost Bride is a long-running Sylvania legend about a woman who outlived three husbands and was buried apart from them. At dawn on the anniversaries of their deaths, her white-clad apparition is said...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Schwarz Castle Rooftop Ghost

CLEVELAND • OHIO

Cleveland's so-called Schwarz Castle is a distinctive nineteenth-century stone residence long surrounded by neighborhood ghost stories. The best-known tradition describes a figure seen on or near the rooftop, sometimes identified as the building's original owner...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Screaming Mimi Bridge

LIBERTY TOWNSHIP • OHIO

The bridge on Maud Hughes Road in Butler County is better known in Ohio ghost lore as Screaming Mimi Bridge. Its legend centers on a woman whose screams are supposedly heard near the bridge after...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Seul Choix Point Lighthouse Captain Townsend and the Haunted Keeper’s House

GULLIVER • MICHIGAN

Seul Choix Point Lighthouse stands on the northern shore of Lake Michigan in Schoolcraft County and has operated as a navigation light since the 1890s. The current tower was first lit in 1895 and was...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Shadyside Flash Flood of 1990

SHADYSIDE • OHIO

On the evening of June 14, 1990, extraordinary rainfall sent walls of water through the Pipe Creek and Wegee Creek valleys near Shadyside in Belmont County. Homes, vehicles and people were swept away with little...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Siege of Fort Meigs and Dudley’s Defeat

PERRYSBURG • OHIO

Fort Meigs was built on the Maumee River in 1813 as a major American base during the War of 1812. That spring, British and Indigenous forces besieged the fort, while a disastrous American counterattack led...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Silver Bridge Collapse Ohio River, 1967

GALLIPOLIS • OHIO

At approximately 5 p.m. on December 15, 1967, the Silver Bridge connecting Point Pleasant, West Virginia, with the Gallipolis, Ohio, area suddenly collapsed into the Ohio River during heavy rush-hour traffic. Thirty-one vehicles fell with...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Simms Cemetery Moving Cemetery Legend

NEW MATAMORAS • OHIO

Simms Cemetery in rural Washington County is associated with an unusual Ohio legend: visitors have claimed that the cemetery seems to move, vanish, change position or become unexpectedly difficult to relocate. The burial ground itself...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Squire’s Castle Ghost Legend

WILLOUGHBY HILLS • OHIO

Squire's Castle is a picturesque stone structure in Cleveland Metroparks' North Chagrin Reservation and the center of a persistent ghost story about Rebecca Squire, wife of Standard Oil executive Feargus B. Squire. The familiar legend...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

St. Jacob Cemetery Kinder Der Nacht

NORTH CANTON • OHIO

St. Jacob Cemetery in Stark County is linked in Ohio paranormal lore to the phrase “Kinder der Nacht,” German for “children of the night.” Modern retellings describe mysterious children, child-sized figures, voices or other unsettling...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Stage’s Pond Horse-and-Buggy Legend

ASHVILLE • OHIO

Stage's Pond State Nature Preserve in Pickaway County is associated with a ghost story involving the sound or apparition of an old horse-drawn buggy. The natural area is historically real and publicly protected; the phantom...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Staley Road Crybaby Bridge Legend

NEW CARLISLE • OHIO

Staley Road near New Carlisle is associated with one of Ohio's many “Crybaby Bridge” traditions. The story says visitors can hear the cries of an unseen infant or child near a bridge or creek crossing,...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Stan Hywet Hall Lady in Gray

AKRON • OHIO

Stan Hywet Hall, the Akron estate built for Goodyear co-founder F. A. Seiberling and his family, is one of Ohio's best-documented historic homes. It also has a quieter supernatural reputation, including stories of a female...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Stroud’s Run Phantom Buffalo and Buried Treasure

ATHENS • OHIO

Strouds Run State Park near Athens carries two unusual strands of local folklore: stories of a phantom buffalo and tales of treasure hidden somewhere in the surrounding hills. Both traditions fit the broader body of...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Summit Lake Drowned Children and Clown Legend

AKRON • OHIO

Akron's Summit Lake has accumulated dark local stories involving drowned children and, in a stranger modern variation, a frightening clown associated with the water or nearby parkland. Summit Lake has a genuine history of recreation,...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

The Elmore Rider / Headless Motorcycle Ghost

ELMORE • OHIO

The Elmore Rider is one of northwest Ohio's best-known roadside ghost legends: a motorcycle rider, often described as headless, is said to appear along a rural road near Elmore and race or follow passing vehicles...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

The Great Black Swamp

NORTHWEST OHIO • OHIO

The Great Black Swamp once covered a vast portion of northwestern Ohio and northeastern Indiana: a seasonally flooded landscape of forests, wetlands, standing water and notoriously difficult travel. It shaped Indigenous travel, military campaigns and...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

The Oliver House

TOLEDO • OHIO

Built in 1859, Toledo's Oliver House is a surviving pre-Civil War hotel building near the Maumee River that now houses Maumee Bay Brewing Company and related hospitality spaces. Its long history has produced an equally...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

The Ridges / Athens Lunatic Asylum

ATHENS • OHIO

The hilltop complex now called The Ridges opened in 1874 as the Athens Lunatic Asylum and later operated under several names, including Athens State Hospital. Designed according to nineteenth-century ideas about moral treatment, the institution...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Tindall Bridge Crybaby Legend

WASHINGTON COURT HOUSE • OHIO

Tindall Bridge in Fayette County is associated with a Crybaby Bridge legend in which visitors are said to hear an unseen infant or child crying near the crossing. As with many Ohio legends of this...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Tinker’s Hollow Gold Ghost

BEDFORD • OHIO

Tinkers Hollow, an old settlement area in southeastern Cuyahoga County, is associated with a persistent lost-gold story and a ghost said to remain near the place where treasure was supposedly hidden. The setting has genuine...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Toledo State Hospital

TOLEDO • OHIO

Opened in 1888 as the Toledo Asylum for the Insane, Toledo State Hospital was an ambitious state psychiatric institution built around a detached-cottage plan rather than one enormous asylum block. Its early campus was designed...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Toledo Yacht Club Ghost Stories

TOLEDO • OHIO

The Toledo Yacht Club has occupied its distinctive clubhouse near the Maumee River and western Lake Erie since the early twentieth century. Alongside its documented maritime and social history is a collection of ghost stories...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Wilson Hall Room 428 Legend

ATHENS • OHIO

Room 428 in Wilson Hall is one of Ohio University’s most persistent campus legends. Stories describe unexplained objects, a door behaving strangely and, most dramatically, a female student who supposedly practiced occult or spiritual techniques...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →

Witch’s Grave West Branch State Park

RAVENNA • OHIO

Deep in the folklore surrounding West Branch State Park is an old family burial ground commonly associated with the 'Witch’s Grave.' The legend says a woman accused of witchcraft was killed or later removed from...

DIG UP THIS ENTRY →